On the opening page of this web site I site Fever-Tree as being the main factor that altered my relationship with Gin and Tonic. So I thought do a post on Fever-Tree, but didn’t want it to just be the same old same old thing (deliberately double same olds). An experiment was designed to compare the following four Fever-Tree tonics – Indian, Naturally Light, Elderflower and Mediterranean.
We, the other half and I, conducted a blind taste test on these three remarkably different tonics with two different Gins, one we like – Copper House, and one we do not particularly care for – Blackdown.
Both the gin and their respective tonic waters were measured equally, so we had eight identical proportioned glasses, with no garnish except for an equal amount of ice; even the glasses themselves were the same.
The results were unexpected – I assumed my preference would be for the standard Indian, with the Mediterranean coming second, but in the end the Indian tonic fell into overall second place behind the Elderflower. We both found that the Elderflower was our favourite with the Copper House and it then scored well with the Blackdown On balance the Indian Tonic came out in second overall place, with the Mediterranean just edging the Naturally Light into fourth place.
I intend to try the Elderflower Tonic Water with more gins from now on, I’m interested to see how it might marry with a variety of different gins and see if perhaps, as it did with the Blackdown, it might elevate some of the gins that I have been less impressed with.
It has also taught me not to believe everything you read – the Ginventory App, of which I am a big fan, recommends the Fever-Tree Mediterranean with Adnams Copper House, and yet when blind taste testing I scored it lowest out of the four mixers.
So having been surprised by the result, I will be conducting more varied blind tests with a bigger samples in blog posts to come. The moral of this post is, however, don’t make your mind up about what your preferred tonic might be – instead be a little adventurous – mix it up. Literally.